Jimmy Tata breaks silence, backs Tata Sons listing and Chandrasekaran

Ratan Tata’s 86-year-old brother backs a listing and Chandrasekaran’s new term, and urges the RBI to set a deadline for listing.

Join the conversation
N Chandrasekaran, chairman of Tata Sons
N Chandrasekaran, chairman of Tata Sons. File photo. — AFP
Listen to this articleJimmy Tata breaks silence, backs Tata Sons listing and Chandrasekaran4 min · device voice0:00 / 3:56

— Jimmy Tata, the oldest trustee of Tata Trusts and the younger brother of the late Ratan Tata, has spoken publicly for the first time about the dispute inside the Tata group. He backs a stock market listing of Tata Sons and a fresh term for chairman N Chandrasekaran, according to reports on Monday.

Jimmy Tata, 86, lives in a modest apartment in Pune and is often described as a recluse. His views were set out in a signed statement that followed a conversation with Vijay Singh, a vice-chairman of Tata Trusts. Singh said he wrote down the comments four or five days ago, sent them to Jimmy Tata for approval, and got the approved text back by courier a few days later.

Listing and secrecy

Tata Trusts hold about 66 percent of Tata Sons, while Jimmy Tata owns about 0.81 percent. He said a listing, which the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) requires, had become “all the more critical” given recent developments. In his view it would end a long-standing culture of secrecy, bring statutory accountability, and force a rewrite of the Articles of Association to restore the separation between business operations and welfare trusts that existed before 1989.

He noted that Tata Sons benefited when Tata Consultancy Services went public under Ratan Tata, and warned that any move to break the group into smaller entities to stay below the RBI’s threshold would damage public and shareholder interests. He urged the central bank to set firm timelines for listing, and asked the government and the Charity Commissioner to step in to protect the original objects of the trusts.

Veto power and Chandrasekaran

Jimmy Tata objected to what he called “unnatural, dictatorial veto powers” given to the chairman of Tata Trusts, the largest shareholder in Tata Sons. He said that, despite strong support on the Tata Sons board and a unanimous resolution of the Trusts, Noel Tata, the current chairman, sought to block Chandrasekaran by invoking that veto without giving a reason. Some reports of the exchange carry his accusation that Noel Tata was pursuing a back-door takeover of Tata Sons.

The Tata Sons board voted 4-1 on September 17 to give Chandrasekaran a new five-year term, with Noel Tata the only director to vote against. Jimmy Tata also raised concerns about appointments of people linked to the Trusts chairman’s family, saying trustees are custodians of charitable assets, not owners, and criticised changes made to the Articles around 2013-14 that he said strengthened the chairman’s hand.

Noel Tata’s position

Noel Tata, who is chairman of Tata Trusts, a nominee director on the Tata Sons board, and holds about 1 percent of Tata Sons, repeated his opposition to listing at a media event on Saturday. He said a listing would change the “Tata way” by putting profit ahead of philanthropy.

Singh and fellow vice-chairman Venu Srinivasan wrote to Darius Khambata days ago backing a listing and asking whether the opposition was really about preserving the present Trusts leadership’s control over Tata Sons. The Bombay High Court is due to hear a public interest petition on Tata Sons’ governance, listing, and private-company status on December 2.

TT Business Desk

Economy, markets and business news from The Thursday Times' business desk.

More from this desk

The conversation

Comments are open on this story. An editor reads every one before it appears.

No one has said anything yet. Be the first.

Published by Thursday Media International thursday.media