India offers Agniveers two more years as Agnipath scheme faces scrutiny

The offer of two extra years at higher pay for recruits not kept on permanently has revived debate over the four-year Agnipath model, with critics citing training, unit cohesion, and cost.

Join the conversation
Soldiers in camouflage lying on a firing range during training in India
Soldiers train on a firing range in India. File photo. — AFP/Getty Images
Listen to this articleIndia offers Agniveers two more years as Agnipath scheme faces scrutiny4 min · device voice0:00 / 3:38

— India has offered the first recruits under its four-year Agnipath scheme a chance to serve two more years at higher pay, a change that has reopened the argument over whether short contracts can build a dependable fighting force.

Chief of Defence Staff General NS Raja Subramani announced on 4 November that recruits, known as Agniveers, who are not selected for permanent positions will be offered a further two years of service. After that they can compete again to join the regular forces, provided they meet the selection criteria. He said the decision followed feedback from the services and that Agnipath would continue.

When the scheme began in 2022, young men and women entering the military were to serve for four years, with only a quarter kept on permanently. The rest were to return to civilian life with a lump-sum payment but no pension. More than 18,300 recruits from the first batch are due to finish their initial term by the end of 2026, and officials say the new arrangement will be offered to more than 300,000 Agniveers now serving in the army, navy, and air force. It is not clear whether future batches will be covered.

What supporters and critics say

The defence ministry has defended Agnipath, saying its internal assessments found the recruits to be physically fit, motivated, and quick to adapt to technology, and that the scheme has widened recruitment across districts and made the process more standardised.

Retired Major General Yash Mor, a vocal critic, argues that it takes eight to nine years to turn a raw recruit into a dependable soldier able to handle a tank or artillery crew, and that unit spirit cannot be built quickly. Sanjiv Krishan Sood, a former additional director general of the Border Security Force, has said the short training period is a particular problem for technical roles, though he believes the extra two years could help recruits learn to use specialised equipment. Air Vice Marshal Shekhar Yadav has welcomed the extension, saying it will let the forces keep trained personnel for longer.

Experts also warn of friction inside units, where regular soldiers, Agniveers on four-year contracts, and those serving the extra two years could end up working side by side on different pay, promotion prospects, and post-service benefits. Cost is another question: almost half of India’s defence budget goes on salaries and pensions, and Agnipath was meant to ease that burden. Retired Major General Birender Singh Dhanoa has asked whether shorter service makes financial sense when training for modern equipment is so expensive.

The opposition Congress party has called the revision a “u-turn” and alleged that the government is responding to fears of losing votes. Elections are due soon in Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, and Uttarakhand, states that have long supplied large numbers of soldiers.

TT Defence Desk

Defence and security news from The Thursday Times' defence desk.

More from this desk

The conversation

Comments are open on this story. An editor reads every one before it appears.

No one has said anything yet. Be the first.

Published by Thursday Media International thursday.media