ISLAMABAD (The Thursday Times) — The Federal Constitutional Court has rejected the JUI-F’s claim to a women’s reserved seat in the National Assembly, ruling that the party’s inability to file an election petition before a tribunal does not justify stretching the constitutional jurisdiction of the superior courts to settle an election dispute.
In a six-page judgment written by Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan, the court said the Islamabad High Court had “rightly declined to resolve disputed electoral claims in constitutional jurisdiction”. The Federal Constitutional Court said its concurrence was confined to that conclusion and the refusal of relief.
The dispute began when the JUI-F submitted its priority list for women’s reserved seats for the 2024 general elections and the Election Commission of Pakistan declared Sadaf Ihsan elected against a seat allocated to the party. The JUI-F later disputed her nomination, saying its list carried the name of Sadaf Yasmin, a different person.
A division bench led by the chief justice held that the dispute raised questions of fact about the authenticity and legal effect of the nomination documents, which could not be conclusively settled in constitutional jurisdiction.
The court noted that under Article 51(6) of the Constitution, women’s reserved seats are filled through proportional representation from party lists. Section 104 of the Elections Act, 2017 requires parties to submit separate priority lists within the prescribed period and bars later changes to candidates or their order of priority. The judgment said an election officer cannot bring an outsider into a party’s list, or substitute one candidate for another, merely because their names are similar.
The order added that observations by the election commission, the Islamabad High Court or the Federal Constitutional Court on nomination, membership or alleged impersonation do not conclusively decide those issues in competent election proceedings. Recourse to the statutory remedy “remains subject to limitation and all other requirements of maintainability”, the judgment said.



