LONDON (The Thursday Times) — A government-commissioned review led by the former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn has called for a “complete system reset” to tackle Britain’s youth jobs crisis, proposing a new welfare system for under-25s paired with a legal entitlement to support into work or training. The review was published on Tuesday, 17 November.
Almost one million people aged 16 to 24 in the UK are not in education, employment or training, known as Neets, a rate of 13 per cent. Milburn wants that cut to around 5 per cent within a decade, and the review says sweeping reforms are needed to help 440,000 more young people into work. “A complete system reset is needed. A lost generation is not inevitable. A work generation is possible,” Milburn said.
At the heart of the plan is a new “Youth Opportunity Service” in England, which would give young people a legal entitlement to support and a named adviser, with the aim of securing an apprenticeship, college place, supported job or job within four months. The review also calls for 90 per cent of children to be school-ready with basic life skills by the age of five, up from 68 per cent in England now, more work skills in the school curriculum, instant access to mental health support without a diagnosis, a doubling of young apprentices, and lower employer National Insurance for young workers.
To help pay for the changes, young adults would no longer be eligible for the health top-up of Universal Credit or for Personal Independence Payment. They would instead receive a Youth Allowance at the current base rate of Universal Credit for young people and a new Additional Cost Allowance, while those who can never work would be supported through a new Severe and Complex Needs Insurance. The review says that in 2024/25 the state spent £25 on youth benefits for every £1 spent helping young people into work or education, and wants the balance to reach £2 on benefits for every £1 on work support by 2036.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has promised that any changes to benefits will come with a “root and branch rethink” of youth support. Work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden told Labour MPs the proposal was “a new settlement for young people”, adding: “This is not last year’s proposal with better PR.”
Many of the proposals apply to England only, although some welfare and tax measures would apply across the UK. The Institute for Fiscal Studies has said reforms are likelier to succeed if support for young people is balanced with incentives for businesses to hire them, and that cutting benefit entitlements would reduce young people’s cash immediately while it may take longer for higher employment to make up for it.
Opposition parties were critical. The Conservatives’ shadow work and pensions secretary, Helen Whately, said parts of the review were “too cautious” and leaned on the “expensive hand of the state”. The Liberal Democrats’ deputy leader, Daisy Cooper, said cutting National Insurance for young workers would “only partly undo the damage of Labour’s job tax”. Reform UK’s Suella Braverman said a ten-year wait would be “consigning another generation to the scrap heap”.
Left-wing Labour MPs, including Nadia Whittome, Bell Ribeiro-Addy and John McDonnell, wrote before the launch that “what young people need is not more punishment, but more opportunity”, warning that relying on benefit cuts risks further disenfranchising young people who are already struggling.



