NEW YORK (The Thursday Times) — Strict phone restrictions in US schools lead to small academic gains, according to a large study published on Tuesday, 17 November, by Harvard’s Center for Education Policy Research.
The researchers compared the test scores of 3.3 million students in about 4,600 schools. Schools that required students to keep phones in locked pouches for the whole day saw “modest” improvements in academic growth compared with similar schools without such rules. The study estimates the gain at roughly one to two weeks of extra learning over a school year.
“Our answer is yes, phone bans do have a positive effect on growth. But it’s not a panacea,” said Thomas Kane, the Harvard professor who led the work. He said the gain is about half the annual decline in test scores since smartphones became widespread, and that further gains could come if schools keep the bans in place. The study used maths and reading results for grades four to 10 over the past five academic years.
The finding sits uneasily with earlier research. A study published in May by researchers at Stanford, the University of Michigan, Duke, and the University of Pennsylvania, covering the same number of schools using the pouches, found “close to zero” effect on test scores overall, though it did record modest gains in high school maths over three years. One of its authors, Stanford economist Thomas Dee, said the early results from phone bans were “largely disappointing” and that he was not comfortable projecting future gains from small estimates based on a few years of data.
More than 40 US states now have laws restricting phones in schools, but the rules vary widely and enforcement is patchy. San Diego State University psychologist Jean Twenge said some bans were largely cosmetic, with students stowing spare phones in their pouches. Students may also simply move to laptops, and phone use outside school may matter more. Kane said researchers cannot yet test that, because social media companies have not shared data that could link time spent on their platforms to student results.



