NEW YORK (The Thursday Times) — Harvard ke Center for Education Policy Research ki Mangal 17 November ko shaya hone wali ek bari tehqeeq ke mutabiq Amriki schoolon mein phone par sakht pabandiyon se taleemi nataij mein mamooli behtari aati hai.
Muhaqqiqin ne taqriban 4,600 schoolon ke 33 lakh talba ke test score ka muwazna kiya. Jin schoolon mein talba ko poora din phone tala-band pouch mein rakhna parta tha, wahan aisi pabandi ke baghair milte-julte schoolon ke muqable mein taleemi numu mein “mamooli” behtari dekhi gayi. Tehqeeq ke andaze ke mutabiq yeh fayda ek taleemi saal mein taqriban ek se do hafte ki izafi taleem ke barabar hai.
Tehqeeq ki qayadat karne wale Harvard ke professor Thomas Kane ne kaha, “Hamara jawab haan hai, phone par pabandi ka numu par musbat asar parta hai. Lekin yeh har masle ka ilaaj nahin.” Un ke mutabiq yeh fayda smartphone ke aam hone ke baad se test score mein salana kami ke taqriban nisf ke barabar hai, aur agar school pabandiyan barqarar rakhein to mazeed fayda ho sakta hai. Tehqeeq mein guzishta paanch taleemi barson ke chauthi se dusri jamaat tak ke riyazi aur parhne ke nataij istemal kiye gaye.
Yeh nateeja pehle ki tehqeeq se kuch mukhtalif hai. May mein Stanford, University of Michigan, Duke aur University of Pennsylvania ke muhaqqiqin ki shaya kardah tehqeeq mein, jis mein pouch istemal karne wale utne hi school shamil the, majmooi taur par test score par “sifar ke qareeb” asar mila, agarcheh teen baras mein high school ke riyazi mein mamooli behtari zaroor record hui. Us ke ek musannif, Stanford ke maahir-e-maeeshat Thomas Dee ne kaha ke phone pabandiyon ke ibtidai nataij “zyada tar mayoos kun” hain aur woh chand baras ke data par mabni chhote andazon se mustaqbil ke fawaid ka andaza lagane mein mutmain nahin.
Amrika ki 40 se zyada riyaston mein ab schoolon mein phone par pabandi ke qawaneen hain, lekin qawaid bahut mukhtalif hain aur nifaz kamzor hai. San Diego State University ki maahir-e-nafsiyat Jean Twenge ne kaha ke kuch pabandiyan zyada tar dikhawe ki hain, aur talba apne pouch mein faltu phone rakh dete hain. Talba laptop par bhi ja sakte hain, aur school ke bahar phone ka istemal zyada ahem ho sakta hai. Kane ne kaha ke muhaqqiqin abhi is ka jaiza nahin le sakte, kyunke social media companies ne aisa data share nahin kiya jo platforms par guzare gaye waqt ko talba ke nataij se jod sake.



