LONDON (The Thursday Times) — The last deportation flight under the UK-France “one in, one out” pilot is due to leave on Tuesday, and asylum seekers with tickets for it say many of those on board are being sent back to France for a second time after returning to Britain to escape smugglers.
The scheme, run by the Home Office as Operation Hillmore, returned people who crossed the Channel in small boats to France, while a similar number of eligible people in France were brought to the UK through a controlled legal route. It was due to end on 11 June, was extended, and closed on 1 October.
Returned, then sent back again
Hundreds of people who were sent back to France are thought to have returned to the UK, some citing threats from smugglers who said their families still owed money for the Channel crossing. Two asylum seekers with tickets for Tuesday’s flight, who said they had come back a second time, described threats and violence they faced in France. Some said smugglers caught them while they slept on the street and made them work for them in a migrant camp. Their accounts could not be independently checked by TT.
One of the men, who said he was a political dissident from Iran, said he believed returnees like him were being penalised. “I came back to the UK a second time because the smugglers caught me in France,” he said. “I believe those of us who came back to the UK a second time are being punished by being sent back to France a second time.” He said he feared for his life. “I am scared that when I am returned to France on Tuesday, the smugglers will catch me and kill me.” He added that he and others had struggled to get good legal advice, although the Home Office says enough lawyers are available to people detained for the scheme.
What the inspector found
John Tuckett, the Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration, published his report on the pilot on 10 November. He found it had shown that a linked “in” and “out” agreement could be set up and made to work using existing practices that were legally robust, helped by the priority and resources the Home Office gave it. But clear criteria for judging success were not set at the start, which he said makes it hard to assess the pilot’s specific contribution to any fall in small-boat arrivals. The report made three recommendations, and the Home Office has accepted all of them.
Medical Justice, a charity that has supported people detained under the scheme, called it “a disaster” that caused avoidable suffering and failed in its stated aim. A Home Office spokesperson said the pilot had “successfully demonstrated that a returns arrangement of this kind can work”, adding: “The message was clear: if you returned to the UK after being transferred to France under the pilot, you would be sent back.” The spokesperson said the pilot had now concluded and the lessons would be taken forward as part of wider efforts to strengthen returns.



