ISLAMABAD (The Thursday Times) — Pakistan 7 May 2025 se kehta aaya hai ke uski fizaiya ne Bharti tayyare, jin mein Rafale bhi shamil hain, maar giraye, aur woh is moaqif par qaim hai. Bharti fizaiya ke 32 Rafale tayyaron ki ek shaya shuda fehrist, jo Bharat ke order kardah 36 se chaar kam hai, Pakistan ke bayan se mutabiqat rakhti hai, agarchi directory wajah nahin batati. Bharat ne tayyaron ke nuqsan ka aitraf kiya hai magar kabhi yeh nahin bataya ke kitne. Awami record daawon, juzvi aitrafat aur ek fehrist par mushtamil hai. Har ek ki maujooda position yeh hai.
Yeh tadaad 2027 ki World Air Forces directory se li gayi hai, jis ka ahwal hum ne apni markazi report mein diya. Yeh batati hai ke kisi fizaiya ke pas kya maujood dikhaya gaya hai. Yeh nuqsanat ki report nahin.
Larai kaise shuru hui
Yeh takrao 22 April 2025 ko Bharti zer-e-intizam Kashmir mein 26 shehriyon ki halakat ke baad hua, jis ka ilzam New Delhi ne Pakistan par lagaya aur Islamabad ne sakhti se mustarad kiya. Bharat ne 7 May ko Pakistan mein ahdaf ke khilaf Operation Sindoor shuru kiya. Pakistan ne apne jawab ko Bunyan-um-Marsoos ka naam diya. Fizai, drone, missile aur topkhane ki larai 10 May ko jang bandi par khatam hui.
Pakistan ne kya kaha
7 May 2025 ko Pakistan ke askari tarjuman Lieutenant General Ahmed Sharif Chaudhry ne kaha ke paanch Bharti tayyare maar giraye gaye: teen Rafale, ek MiG-29 aur ek Su-30. Pakistan ne baad mein yeh tadaad chhe batayi. October 2025 ke ek interview mein unhon ne ise saat kar diya aur kaha ke Pakistan ka ek bhi tayyara nishana nahin bana.
Pakistan ne fizai maarke ka seharaa apne Chini sakhta J-10C tayyaron ko diya hai jo PL-15 taweel fasle ke missiles se lais the, aur Chini nizamon ki karkardagi ko ghair mamooli taur par mowasir qarar deta hai. Saat tayyaron ki tadaad American sadar Donald Trump ke ek bayan se milti hai jinhon ne Virginia mein taqreer ke dauran kaha ke saat tayyare maar giraye gaye, magar yeh nahin bataya ke kis ne.
Bharat ne kya kaha
Bharat ne Rafale ke nuqsanat ki koi tadaad jari nahin ki. 31 May 2025 ko Singapore mein Chief of Defence Staff General Anil Chauhan ne tasleem kiya ke Bharti tayyare gire hain magar tadaad batane se inkar kiya. Unhon ne kaha: “Aham baat yeh nahin ke tayyare giraye gaye, balke yeh hai ke kyun giraye gaye.”
Bharti fizaiya ke sarbarah ne alag se kaha hai ke Bharti afwaj ne taqriban ek darjan Pakistani tayyare tabah kiye. Pakistan ise mustarad karta hai, aur kisi fareeq ne aisa saboot pesh nahin kiya jo doosre ke aadad o shumar ka faisla kar de.
Directory kya izafa karti hai
Directory faal zakhire mein 32 Rafale darj karti hai. Bharat ko apne 36 tayyare 2016 ke order ke tehat 2020 se 2022 ke darmiyan mile, chunancha yeh fehrist us tadaad se chaar kam hai jo New Delhi bede ke liye batata hai. Directory wajah nahin batati, aur bede ka takhmina kisi infiradi nuqsan ka saboot nahin.
Yeh jo izafa karti hai woh sanat ke ek moteber hawale ki jaanib se shaya shuda ek azad adad hai jo Pakistan ke deerina moaqif se mutabiqat rakhta hai aur Bharat ki batayi hui ginti se nahin milta. Bharat, jis ne zaya shuda tayyaron ki apni koi tadaad kabhi nahin batayi, ke samne ab ek shaya shuda adad hai jis ka use jawab dena hai.
Kya baqi hai
Teen cheezein ab bhi khuli hain. Bharat ne zaya shuda tayyaron ki sarkari tadaad, qism ke lihaz se ya mujmui, nahin di. Pakistan ki tadaad paanch se chhe aur phir saat hui magar awami tafseel nahin aayi. Aur kisi azad idare ne kisi bhi fareeq ki mukammal ginti ki tasdeeq nahin ki. Jab tak in mein se koi baat nahin badalti, bede ki fehrist ghair janibdar tareen data point hai, aur woh mamooli sa hai.



