ISLAMABAD (The Thursday Times) — The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) has ruled that parliament’s failure to exercise a fiscal power does not mean the subject has passed to the provinces, striking down the infrastructure development cess imposed by Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
In a 59-page detailed judgement authored by Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan, a two-judge bench of the chief justice and Justice Aamer Farooq decided a set of 568 challenges filed by taxpayers. The detailed ruling follows a verbal order issued a day earlier.
The court allowed the taxpayers’ civil appeals, set aside the judgements of the Sindh High Court and the Peshawar High Court, and declared the corresponding charging provisions, along with all dependent rules, notifications, assessments and recovery measures, unconstitutional and without lawful authority.
“No demand, surcharge or penalty founded solely upon those charges shall be enforced,” the judgement said. Securities furnished solely for the invalid charges will be discharged upon verification, subject to any subsisting order on their disposal.
The common question before the court was whether the levies, in their true nature, fell within provincial legislative competence or encroached on parliament’s exclusive authority over imports, exports and interprovincial trade.
“An identified conflict with a competent federal law attracts the consequence prescribed under Article 142 of the Constitution, meaning that the federal law will prevail whereas the provincial law becomes void to the extent of that conflict,” the chief justice observed.
The court said Article 160 and the National Finance Commission arrangements distinguish between the power to levy a federal tax and the entitlement to its proceeds. “A province’s share does not authorise it to impose that tax independently,” the judgement said, adding that the defect was legislative incompetence, not duplication, and that fiscal need could not supply the missing power.
It observed that the high courts had given controlling weight to the infrastructure purpose of the cess, the movement of goods and its asserted compensatory character without first establishing provincial legislative competence. The abolition of the Concurrent Legislative List under the 18th Amendment, it said, expanded provincial competence but did not transfer subjects expressly retained in the federal domain.
The provinces remain free to enact constitutionally competent infrastructure or service charges on goods manufactured and consumed within their own territories, the court ruled. It said provincial autonomy must be given full effect within its constitutional sphere while preserving parliament’s exclusive authority over reserved matters.
The taxpayers had argued that the levies encroached on parliament’s exclusive domain and could not be sustained as fees merely because the goods used provincial roads. They also challenged the collection arrangements, discriminatory treatment, trade restrictions and retrospective validation. The provinces cited their residual legislative powers, infrastructure responsibilities and the services provided to commercial users, and argued the cess was distinct from customs duties.



