FCC ne Sindh aur KP ka infrastructure cess ghair aini qarar de diya

Adalat ke mutabiq Parliament ke ghair istemal shuda ikhtiyarat suboon ko muntaqil nahin hote, aur 568 darkhwaston par High Courts ke faislay kaalam qarar diye gaye.

Raaye dein

Tarjuma ho raha hai… 4 / 4 Asal tehreer parhein

Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and judges of the Federal Constitutional Court
Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan aur Wafaqi Aini Adalat ke judges 13 November 2026 ko Islamabad mein adalat ke yadgari dak ticket ki taqreeb-e-runumai mein. File photo. — APP

— Wafaqi Aini Adalat ne qarar diya hai ke Parliament ka kisi maali ikhtiyar ko istemal na karna is baat ka matlab nahin ke woh mauzu suboon ko muntaqil ho gaya, aur isi bunyad par Sindh aur Khyber Pakhtunkhwa ka aaid kiya hua infrastructure development cess kaalam qarar de diya hai.

Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan ke likhe 59 safhaat par mushtamil tafseeli faisle mein Chief Justice aur Justice Aamer Farooq par mushtamil do rukni bench ne tax dehendgan ki taraf se dayer 568 darkhwaston ka faisla sunaya. Tafseeli faisla ek roz pehle sunaye gaye zubani hukm ke baad jaari hua.

Adalat ne tax dehendgan ki diwani appeals manzoor karte hue Sindh High Court aur Peshawar High Court ke faislay kaalam kar diye, aur muta’alliqa charging dafaat samet tamam matehat qawaid, notifications, tashkhisaat aur wusooli ke iqdamaat ko ghair aini aur bila qanooni ikhtiyar qarar diya.

Faisle mein kaha gaya: “Sirf in mahsoolaat ki bunyad par koi mutalba, surcharge ya jurmana nafiz nahin kiya jayega.” Faisle ke mutabiq jo zamanatein sirf ghair qanooni mahsoolaat ke liye di gayi thin woh tasdeeq ke baad wapas kar di jayengi, bashart ye ke un ke tasarruf se mutaliq koi maujooda hukm na ho.

Adalat ke samne bunyadi sawal ye tha ke kya ye mahsoolaat apni haqeeqat mein suba’i qanoon sazi ke daire mein aate hain ya daramadaat, bar-amadaat aur bain-ul-suba’i tijarat par Parliament ke khusoosi ikhtiyar mein mudakhilat hain.

Chief Justice ne likha: “Kisi mujaaz wafaqi qanoon se wazeh takrao Constitution ke Article 142 ke tehat nateeja paida karta hai, yaani wafaqi qanoon ghalib rahega aur suba’i qanoon is takrao ki had tak kaalam ho jayega.”

Adalat ne kaha ke Article 160 aur National Finance Commission ke intizamaat wafaqi tax lagane ke ikhtiyar aur us ki aamdani mein hisse ke istehqaq ke darmiyan farq karte hain. Faisle mein kaha gaya: “Kisi suba ka hissa use ye tax azadana taur par lagane ka ikhtiyar nahin deta.” Adalat ke mutabiq kharabi dohre tax ki nahin balkay qanoon sazi ke ikhtiyar ki kami ki thi, aur maali zaroorat matlooba ikhtiyar ki jagah nahin le sakti.

Adalat ne mushahida kiya ke High Courts ne cess ke infrastructure maqsad, saman ki naql-o-harkat aur us ke mabeena muawza jaati kirdar ko faisla kun ahmiyat di, jabke pehle suba’i qanoon sazi ka ikhtiyar sabit nahin kiya. Adalat ke mutabiq 18wein tarmeem ke tehat Concurrent Legislative List ke khatme se suba’i ikhtiyarat mein izafa hua, magar woh mauzuat muntaqil nahin hue jo sarahat ke saath wafaq ke paas rakhe gaye the.

Adalat ne qarar diya ke suboon apni hudood mein tayyar aur istemal hone wali ashya par aini taur par mujaaz infrastructure ya service charges lagane ke liye azad rahenge. Us ka kehna tha ke suba’i khudmukhtari ko us ke aini daire mein poori tarah moassar hona chahiye, aur saath hi mehfooz muamlaat par Parliament ka khusoosi ikhtiyar barqarar rehna chahiye.

Tax dehendgan ka mauqif tha ke ye mahsoolaat Parliament ke khusoosi daire mein mudakhilat hain aur mahaz is bina par fees qarar nahin diye ja sakte ke saman ne suba’i sarkein istemal keen. Unhon ne wusooli ke intizamaat, imtiyazi salook, tijarti pabandiyon aur sabiqa tareekh se tauseeq ko bhi challenge kiya. Suboon ne apne baqaya qanoon sazi ke ikhtiyarat, infrastructure ki zimmedariyon aur tijarti sarifeen ko faraham kardah khidmaat ka hawala diya, aur mauqif apnaya ke cess customs duty se mukhtalif hai.

TT Court Reporter

Courts and the law, from The Thursday Times' court reporter.

More from this desk

The conversation

Comments are open on this story. An editor reads every one before it appears.

No one has said anything yet. Be the first.

Published by Thursday Media International thursday.media