NEW DELHI (The Thursday Times) — Bharat ki Supreme Court ne Monday ko National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) ke is ikhtiyar ki tauseeq kar di ke woh manzoor shuda diwaliya hal plan qarz khwahon ko wapas bhej sakta hai, aur 13 Videocon group companiyon ke liye 2,962 crore rupay ki boli par uske 2022 ke hukm ke khilaf appeelein khaarij kar deen.
Justice PS Narasimha aur Justice Alok Aradhe par mushtamil bench ne adalat mein faisle ka amli hissa suna diya. Bench ne kaha, “Hum ne NCLAT ke is ikhtiyar ko barqarar rakha hai ke woh manzoor shuda hal plan Committee of Creditors ko wapas bhej sakta hai.” Bench ke mutabiq tamam appeelein unhi wujuhaat ki bina par khaarij ki gayin jo usne bayan keen. Bench ne yeh bhi rehnuma usool tay kiye ke yeh ikhtiyar kaise istemal ho sakta hai. Tafseeli faisle ka intezar hai.
95 fisad katauti
Twinstar Technologies ne Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code ke tehat 13 Videocon companiyan khareedne ki pesh-kash ki thi. Mumbai mein National Company Law Tribunal ne uske 2,962 crore rupay ke plan ki 8 June 2021 ko manzoori di thi. Tasleem shuda wajibaat taqriban 65,000 crore rupay thay, yaani qarz khwahon ke liye 95 fisad se zyada katauti. Committee of Creditors ke 95.09 fisad vote rakhne wale qarz khwahon ne plan ki himayat ki thi.
Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI aur SIDBI ne manzoori ko NCLAT mein challenge kiya. Unhon ne apne liye mukhtass raqoom par aitraaz kiya, aur is tajweez par bhi ke unhein aise non-convertible debentures ke zariye adaigi ki jaye jo taqriban paanch saal baad qabil-e-wapsi honge.
Appellate tribunal ne kya paya
5 January 2022 ko NCLAT ne manzoori kalam adam qarar de kar plan Committee of Creditors ko wapas bhej diya. Usne qarar diya ke plan ikhtilaf karne wale maali qarz khwahon ko adaigi ke liye Code ke tahaffuzaat par poora nahi utarta, aur unhein wajib-ul-ada raqam ke badle securities lene par majboor nahi kiya ja sakta. Tribunal ne resolution professional ke taameeli certificate ke aadad o shumar aur taqseem ke hisabaat mein farq ki bhi nishandahi ki.
NCLAT ne yeh bhi paya ke voting se pehle Competition Commission of India ki manzoori hasil nahi ki gayi thi. Uske bamujib qanooni taameel ko qarz khwahon ki tijarati danish ka mamla nahi samjha ja sakta. 94.98 fisad vote rakhne wale qarz khwahon ne, jinhon ne pehle plan ki himayat ki thi, baad mein bhaari katauti ka hawala de kar us par nazar-e-sani maangi. Phir Twinstar ne Supreme Court mein appeal ki.
Yeh kyun aham hai
Plan manzoor hone ke baad adalatein taweel arse se qarz khwahon ki tijarati danish ko bari had tak adalati jaanch se bala-tar samajhti aayi hain. Yeh faisla tasdeeq karta hai ke is riayat ki haddein hain: jahan plan qanooni taqazon par poora na utre, wahan appellate tribunal usay mehez manzoor ya mustarad karne ke bajaye qarz khwahon ko wapas bhej sakta hai. Faisle se Videocon ke qarz khwahon ke liye plan par dobara ghaur ka rasta khulta hai, aur tawaqqo hai ke mukammal faisla jari hone ke baad yeh rehnuma usool aainda challenges ki shakl mutayyan karenge.



