Supreme Court rules Abu Dhabi court decree cannot be enforced in Pakistan

A 2-1 majority held that only the UAE’s Federal Court of Appeal is recognised under a 2007 notification, setting aside Lahore High Court orders.

Join the conversation
The Supreme Court of Pakistan building in Islamabad
The Supreme Court of Pakistan building in Islamabad. File photo. — REUTERS
Listen to this articleSupreme Court rules Abu Dhabi court decree cannot be enforced in Pakistan3 min · device voice0:00 / 2:47

— The Supreme Court has ruled that a decree issued by the Abu Dhabi Court of Appeal cannot be directly enforced in Pakistan under Section 44-A of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), according to a judgment announced on 19 November.

By a 2-1 majority, the court held that a 2007 federal government notification recognises only the UAE’s Federal Court of Appeal as a superior court for that purpose. It set aside orders of the Lahore High Court (LHC) and a district court, which had rejected a Pakistani company’s objections to the execution of a commercial decree issued by Abu Dhabi courts.

The majority comprised Justice Munib Akhtar and referee judge Justice Muhammad Shafi Siddiqui. Justice Irfan Saadat Khan wrote a dissenting opinion. The case went to Justice Siddiqui after Justice Akhtar and Justice Khan, who made up the original bench, gave conflicting opinions. The bench had reserved its decision on 10 February 2026.

Federal and local courts

The court observed that the UAE is a federation of seven emirates with separate federal and local judicial systems, and that decisions of an emirate’s local courts cannot be treated as federal judicial decisions merely because they sit in appeal. Justice Akhtar held that the Abu Dhabi Court of Appeal belongs to the emirate’s local system and cannot be equated with the UAE’s Federal Court of Appeal for the purposes of Section 44-A.

The dispute

The case arose from a 2011 commercial agreement between Engineering Kinetics (Private) Limited and an Abu Dhabi-based company for the manufacture and installation of pipes. After a dispute, the Abu Dhabi Court of First Instance directed the Pakistani company on 17 June 2014 to pay damages, and the Abu Dhabi Court of Appeal upheld the decision on 20 January 2015.

The decree-holder then asked a district court in Lahore to execute the judgment under Section 44-A. The company objected that the Abu Dhabi Court of Appeal was not a superior court recognised by the 2007 notification. The district court dismissed the objections, and the LHC upheld that decision on 25 November 2022, after which the company came to the Supreme Court.

TT Court Reporter

Courts and the law, from The Thursday Times' court reporter.

More from this desk

The conversation

Comments are open on this story. An editor reads every one before it appears.

No one has said anything yet. Be the first.

Published by Thursday Media International thursday.media