Why the Madras High Court was right to cancel a missionary’s OCI card

“The expression ‘missionary activity’ is wider than trying to convert,” writes former Supreme Court of India Justice Markandey Katju, backing the Madras High Court’s refusal to restore an American OCI cardholder’s status.

رائے دیں

انگریزی سے ترجمہ ہو رہا ہے… 0 از 5 اصل تحریر پڑھیں

The red Indo-Saracenic domes and towers of the Madras High Court building in Chennai
مدراس ہائی کورٹ کی چنئی میں واقع عمارت۔ فائل فوٹو۔ — پی ٹی آئی
یہ تحریر سنیںWhy the Madras High Court was right to cancel a missionary’s OCI card8 منٹ · آلے کی آواز0:00 / 8:15

Many Indians who settle in America, Canada or some other foreign country and become citizens of those countries, get themselves registered as an OCI (Overseas Citizen of India). On obtaining such registration they can come to India without obtaining an Indian visa.

However, the Government of India has put some restrictions on OCI cardholders, one of them being that they cannot do missionary activity in India without a special permission from the Government of India.

John Daniel is one such person of Indian origin who became a US citizen and got an OCI card. He has many relatives living in Tamil Nadu, and he often visited India without an Indian visa.

However, now the Indian government has cancelled his OCI registration, which means he has to leave India, and cannot visit India again without obtaining an Indian visa.

He challenged the cancellation of his OCI card by filing a writ petition in the Madras High Court, but that petition has been dismissed on 26 October 2026 (John Daniel v. Union of India and Others, 2026 MHC 4303).

The ground given by the government for cancellation was that while in India he conducted missionary activity and tried to convert people to Christianity without permission from the Government of India.

He denied these allegations, and stated that he only came to India to visit his relatives in Tamil Nadu, but the High Court held that even if he did not try to convert people, he was doing missionary activity in India without getting permission from the government. The Court, while dismissing his petition observed:

“Substantial materials have been produced against the petitioner, indicating that he has consistently been addressing congregations, gatherings and meetings at various places in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh and that advertisements have been issued inviting the general public to attend his meetings. Those materials cannot be regarded by this Court as fabricated or concocted. It is one thing to contend that the petitioner is not involved in conversion and is only spreading the message of ‘God’. However, it is not only for conversion, but even to be a missionary preaching his religion, it is only a prior permission that is mandated. The petitioner has made a categorical and sweeping statement before this Court that he has never been involved in any missionary activities in India and has visited India only to see his mother, family and friends, which, on its face is a lie.”

So unless he appeals against this decision before the Indian Supreme Court, and obtains a stay of the High Court verdict, he will have to go back to America, and cannot come again to India without obtaining an Indian visa.

Is this verdict correct? I am of the opinion that it is entirely correct.

The expression ‘missionary activity’ is wider than trying to convert.

Missionary activity is defined as being sent to share faith and serve others, often across cultural or geographic boundaries. It includes preaching the Gospel, providing education, healthcare, and showing love through daily actions.

Thus, missionary activity is not limited to trying to convert. It includes providing education, healthcare, etc. Many describe missionary activity as an attitude of love and service wherever you are. It is not only about preaching or traveling overseas — it is about kindness, helping neighbors, and living out faith in homes, schools, and workplaces. Some say mothers, teachers, and health workers are missionaries too when they guide, comfort, and serve others in Jesus’ name.

In this connection an interesting incident may be mentioned.

Shortly after the victory of the communists in China in 1949, a delegation of Western missionaries met Prime Minister Zhou Enlai in Beijing to request permission to continue entering China and preaching there, as they had been doing for many years.

Zhou replied:

“We will permit as many of your missionaries to enter China and preach here, as you allow our missionaries to enter your countries and preach there.”

As to what religion these Chinese missionaries entering Western countries would preach was not mentioned by Zhou, but was understood by all. Western governments would surely never allow a host of communists to enter their countries and spread communist propaganda there. The attempt of the delegation therefore failed, and foreign missionaries were expelled from China, and never allowed to re-enter.

Some people say that Western countries permit Hindus from India to come to their country and preach Hinduism there, so why should India not reciprocate?

There are two things to be said in reply to this:

(1) Just because Western countries permit Hindus to come to their countries and preach Hinduism there, it does not follow that India too must do the same.

Every country is sovereign, according to the Treaty of Westphalia, 1648, which laid down the Westphalian principle of national sovereignty, which has been reaffirmed in the UN Charter.

So India has the right to have its own visa rules, and is not obligated to follow the rules in Western countries.

(2) Religion is a feature of feudal or semi-feudal society, not of an industrialised society.

In developed, highly industrialised countries like the USA, the hold of religion on the masses is much weaker than in underdeveloped countries like India (the real God of America is the dollar). So preaching Hinduism in the USA is not likely to create a social disturbance.

On the other hand, India is still semi-feudal (as is evident from the rampant casteism and communalism prevalent here, which are feudal forces). Missionary work in India, a country with tremendous diversity, is bound to create social friction and strife.

So we cannot equate the situation in Western countries with that in India.

Some people may say that the example I gave of China is not apt.

My reply to this is:

After its revolution in 1949, China became a sovereign country, and was no longer a semi-colony dominated by foreign powers. So it had the right to expel foreign missionaries, most of whom were hand-in-glove with the imperialist countries and were doing their bidding and furthering their interests.

جسٹس مارکنڈے کاٹجو

جسٹس مارکنڈے کاٹجو بھارتی سپریم کورٹ کے سابق جج ہیں، جہاں وہ 2006 سے 2011 تک خدمات انجام دیتے رہے، اور دہلی اور مدراس ہائی کورٹس کے سابق چیف جسٹس ہیں۔ وہ 2011 سے 2014 تک پریس کونسل آف انڈیا کے چیئرمین رہے اور بھارتی معاشرے، سیاست اور تاریخ پر بکثرت لکھتے ہیں۔

ان کی مزید تحریریں

گفتگو

اس خبر پر رائے دی جا سکتی ہے۔ ہر تبصرہ شائع ہونے سے پہلے ایک ایڈیٹر پڑھتا ہے۔

ابھی کسی نے کچھ نہیں کہا۔ آپ پہلے ہوں۔

ناشر Thursday Media International thursday.media