ISLAMABAD (The Thursday Times) — July se, jab Wazir-e-Dakhila Mohsin Naqvi ne kaha ke nizam-e-hukmrani nakam ho chuka hai aur mazeed suboon ya intizami units ka mutalba kiya, chhote suboon par Pakistan ki behas ek hi sawal tak simat aayi hai: faisla kaun karega? Awami vote ke hami kehte hain ke jawab awam hain. Pakistan Peoples Party kehti hai ke jawab Aain mein pehle se likha hai. 21 November ko dono daawon mein wazan hai, aur dono ki abhi azmaish nahin hui, kyunke na koi bill hai, na cabinet ka faisla, aur na Election Commission ko koi bazabta darkhwast.
Behas is waqt kahan khari hai
Tarteeb aham hai. 31 July ko Naqvi ne Islamabad mein ek iqtisadi summit mein apna mutalba rakha, jis se pehle Wazir-e-Sehat Mustafa Kamal, jo MQM-PMuttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan, Sindh ki shehri jamaat jo wafaqi ittehad mein shamil hai aur suba mein mazeed intizami units ka mutalba karti hai. ke sarbarah hain, Sindh ki taqseem ki baat chhed chuke the. 4 September ko Sindh Assembly ne suba taqseem karne ki har koshish ko mustarad karne ki qarardad manzoor ki, aur Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah ne kaha ke suba ki jughrafiyai wahdat par koi samjhauta nahin hoga. 14 November ko Naqvi ki taraf se referendum ki tajweez ke baad Sadar Asif Ali Zardari ne Wazir-e-Azam Shehbaz Sharif se mulaqat ki. Teen din baad Karachi Press Club mein PPP ke chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari ne is tajweez ko mustarad kiya aur khabardar kiya ke Sindh ko zabardasti taqseem karne se Karachi aur Hyderabad mein khoonrezi hogi. Sadar aur Wazir-e-Azam ki 19 November ko dobara mulaqat hui aur dono ne ikhtilafat baat cheet se hal karne ka ahd kiya.
20 November ko opposition jamaat PTI aur Wazir-e-Itelaat Attaullah Tarar dono ne kaha ke referendum is mamle ko nimta sakta hai, jabke Wazir-e-Railway Hanif Abbasi ne kaha ke koi faisla nahin hua aur kisi bhi qadam ke liye Parliament ke dono aiwanon ki manzoori darkar hogi, jaisa ke The Thursday Times ne report kiya. Ek din baad Election Commission ne kaha ke use koi darkhwast ya hidayat mausool nahin hui, aur wafaqi cabinet ne is khayal par bazabta behas nahin ki. Party zarai ke mutabiq PML-N, PPP aur MQM-P se mushawarat ka irada rakhti hai, aur ittefaq-e-raye hone ki soorat mein qaumi siyasi conference aur parliamentary committee mumkin hain. Bilawal ishara de chuke hain ke 28vin tarmeem zer-e-ghaur hai, magar kuch bhi pesh nahin kiya gaya. The Thursday Times ka 20 November ka idariya khoonrezi ki zaban ka naqid tha, magar ek nukte par PPP se mutafiq tha: executive ka karaya hua referendum aini rasta nahin hai. Naqshe ki wasi tar behas ke liye dekhiye Pakistan ko 12 suboon dene ke liye kya darkar hoga.
Awam se poochne ka muqaddama
Awami vote ke hami iqtidar-e-aala se aghaz karte hain. Unki daleel hai ke koi subai assembly apne voters ki tarjumani ka daawa us waqt tak nahin kar sakti jab tak un se poocha na gaya ho ke woh kaise hukumat kiye jana chahte hain, aur hukumat hukmrani ko apni marzi ka ehsan nahin samajh sakti. Woh kehte hain ke har suba apne liye vote de, taake koi suba doosre par apni marzi na thope. Unki daleel ke mutabiq agar PPP ko Sindh mein awami raye par aitemad hai to use shaffaf raye shumari se darne ki zaroorat nahin aur nateeje ka khairmaqdam karna chahiye. Woh mazeed kehte hain ke chhoti ikaiyan hukumat ko awam ke qareeb laengi, bureaucracy ko zyada jawabdeh banayengi, aur khidmat aur karkardagi par yaqeen rakhne walon ke liye siyasi gunjaish barhayengi.
Unke paas hawale ke liye ek record bhi hai. Qaumi Assembly mein PTI ke chief whip Aamir Dogar ne kaha ke Imran Khan hamesha chhote suboon ke hami rahe hain aur Junubi Punjab suba party ke 2018 ke manshoor mein shamil tha. Mustafa Kamal ne 20 November ko kaha ke MQM-P is mutalbe ki taraf is liye gayi ke Sindh mein maqami hukumaton ke paas haqiqi ikhtiyarat nahin, aur unki jamaat 26vin ya 27vin tarmeem ki hamayat karti agar usmein maqami hukumaton ko aini ikhtiyar diya jata. Unhon ne Article 239 ki taraf bhi ishara kiya ke Aain yeh tareeqa pehle se faraham karta hai.
“Awam ki marzi aur raye ko ghalib aana chahiye.”
Hami Sindh ki apni intizami taqseem ki tareekh ka bhi hawala dete hain, yani 1973 mein teen division aur 11 azla se aaj saat division aur 30 azla tak, aur poochte hain ke Sindh apni mojooda hudood ke andar suba kyun nahin bana sakta. Is muwazne mein ehtiyat chahiye. Sindh mein ab 30 azla hain, aur divisions ki tadad chhe ya saat hai, is par munhasir ke haal hi mein shamil hone wale Bhambhore ko ginna jaye ya nahin. 1973 ka nuqta-e-aghaz dastaweezi tor par mushkil hai, aur 11 azla ki tadad ki tasdeeq nahin ho saki. Yeh daleel do dhari bhi hai. Division aur azla intizami darje hain jinhein subai hukumat apne ikhtiyar se bana sakti hai, jaisa ke PPP ne, jo 18 saal se Sindh par hukmran hai, kiya hai. Suba mukhtalif noiyat ki ikai hai, jiski apni muqannana, qaumi amdan mein apna hissa, aur Senate mein apni nashistein hoti hain. Pehli baat doosri ko tay nahin karti.
Sindh ki janib se jawabi muqaddama
PPP ka muqaddama teen dalail par tika hai. Pehli daleel tareeqa-e-kaar hai. Bilawal keh chuke hain ke Aain pehle hi ek tareeqa tay karta hai, aur referendum ki baat darasal koi aur rasta dhoondne ke mutaradif hai. Unke bayanat ki reports ke mutabiq unhon ne kaha, “Baat referendum ki nahin, niyat ki hai.” Party ka kehna hai ke woh wahan naye suboon ki mukhalif nahin jahan log unhein chahte hon, aur woh keh chuki hai ke Punjab Assembly qarardad manzoor kar le to Junubi Punjab suba ki raah mein rukawat nahin banegi. Doosri daleel taqseem ka khauf hai. Sindh ko subai haisiyat 1970 hi mein wapas mili, One Unit1955 ki woh scheme jis ne Sindh samet maghribi suboon ko mila kar ek Maghribi Pakistan banaya. Sindh ko subai haisiyat 1970 mein wapas mili. ke barson ke baad, aur Karachi aur Hyderabad nasli tashaddud ki yaadein rakhte hain. Party khabardar karti hai ke mamle ko zabardasti aage barhane se unke laut aane ka khatra hai. Teesri daleel yeh hai ke sarhadein masla nahin hain. Bilawal ka istadlal hai ke hukmrani ke buhran ki jad siyasi aur idara jaati nakamiyan hain, naqsha nahin.
“Baat referendum ki nahin, niyat ki hai.”
Is jawabi muqaddame mein kamzoriyan bhi hain, aur naqideen ne unki nishandehi ki hai. Wuzara ne yaad dilaya hai ke PPP 18 saal se Sindh par hukmran hai aur 26vin aur 27vin tarameem mein poori tarah shareek thi jin par woh ab tanqeed karti hai. Naqideen kehte hain ke khoonrezi ki tanbeeh mauqaf ko sakht karti hai aur mukhalifeen ko aasan jawab de deti hai. Aur yeh bhi kam wazeh hai ke PPP shehri Sindh ko naye suba ke badle mein kya pesh karegi, halanke MQM-P ki bunyadi shikayat, ke maqami hukumaton ke paas bunyadi sahulatein dene ke ikhtiyarat nahin, aisi hai jise maqami hukumaton ki islah naqsha badle baghair hal kar sakti hai.
Aain kya taqaza karta hai
Rasta dono fareeqon ke umoomi aitraf se kahin tang hai. Article 239Aain ka woh hissa jo tarmeem ka tareeqa tay karta hai. Shaq 4 kisi suba ki hudood mein tabdeeli ko us waqt tak rokti hai jab tak us suba ki apni assembly do tihai aksariyat se manzoori na de. ke tehat kisi suba ki hudood badalne wala bill us waqt tak Sadar ke paas dastakhat ke liye nahin ja sakta jab tak us suba ki apni assembly use apni kul rukniyatAiwan ki har nashist, sirf us din mojood arkaan nahin, is liye ghair hazir rukn bill ke khilaf shumar hota hai. ke do tihai se manzoor na kar le. Bill ko pehle Parliament ke har aiwan ki kul rukniyat ke do tihai se bhi guzarna hoga. Referendum ek alag mamla hai. Article 48 Wazir-e-Azam ko ijazat deta hai ke qaumi ahmiyat ka sawal mushtarka ijlasQaumi Assembly aur Senate ka mushtarka ijlas. ke samne rakhe aur, woh manzoor kar le to, use awam ke samne haan ya nahin ke sawal ki shakal mein pesh kare. Is Article mein koi cheez us nateeje ko tarmeem ka mutabadil nahin banati. Ek senior wakeel ke alfaz mein, referendum Article 239 ke taqazon ko nazarandaz nahin kar sakta.
Woh hisab jo faisla karta hai
2025 aur 2026 ki reports ke mutabiq hukmran ittehad Qaumi Assembly ki had se upar, taqreeban 233 se 237 nashiston par, aur Senate ki had se bhi upar hai, is liye wafaqi aiwan asal rukawat nahin. Rukawat Karachi mein hai. Reports ke mutabiq PPP ke paas Sindh Assembly ki 168 nashiston mein se taqreeban 116 hain. Bill rokne ke liye use sirf 57 darkar hain, is liye Sindh se koi naya suba ban sakta hai ya nahin, iska faisla markaz nahin balke Sindh ki razamandi karti hai. Vote ke hami yeh jaante hain, isi liye woh zor dete hain ke Sindh ke log bolein, arkan-e-assembly nahin. Taham poore suba ki raye shumari apna sawal uthati hai. Agar poora Sindh Sindh ki taqseem par vote de to nateeja is par munhasir hoga ke poora suba kaise vote deta hai, sirf shehar nahin, aur kisi ne nahin bataya ke aisa sawal kaise banaya jaye ga.
Is se vote be-faida nahin ho jata. Wazeh nateeja faisle ki siyasi qeemat badal sakta hai, ya to PPP ko aage barhne ki wajah de kar ya wafaqi fareeq ko rukne ki. Kamal keh chuke hain ke Wazir-e-Azam ke paas referendum karane ka ikhtiyar hai, aur PML-N ki apni mushawarat se sawal aur tareeqa-e-kaar nikal sakta hai. Election Commission ki do maah ki tayyari ki muddat ka matlab hai ke kuch bhi jaldi nahin ho sakta, aur MQM-P ne naye suboon ke liye apni 29 November ki rally multavi kar di hai, jabke Kamal ke baqaul takraao ka koi bhi khatra hua to woh peechhe hat jaye gi. Fil haal pehla haqiqi imtihan ballot box nahin hai. Yeh hai ke PPP, MQM-P, aur PML-N kisi aise sawal par mutafiq ho sakte hain ya nahin jise woh Parliament mein le jane ko tayyar hon.
Vote bata sakta hai ke Pakistani kya chahte hain. Unhein de sirf tarmeem sakti hai.
Dono fareeq awam ka naam le sakte hain. Naye suba ki taraf rasta ek hi hai, aur woh Sindh Assembly se guzarta hai.



