Analysis

The road to Islamabad

From calls with Tehran and Gulf capitals to ceasefire diplomacy and marathon talks in Islamabad, Pakistan has inserted itself into the most delicate phase of the U.S.-Iran crisis and emerged as an unlikely broker of dialogue.

Pakistan helped secure a ceasefire that halted direct confrontation, at least temporarily. It brought both sides to the table for the most senior direct talks in decades. And it prevented the collapse of diplomacy after the first round ended without agreement. — MICHAEL MCCALL FOR THE THURSDAY TIMES

The Islamabad Talks did not fail. They opened the next phase

The Islamabad Talks were never designed to deliver an instant grand bargain between Washington and Tehran. Their significance lies in something more foundational: they preserved the ceasefire, brought both sides face to face, defined the central sticking point and opened the door to a second phase of diplomacy.

To call the Islamabad talks a failure is to misunderstand the nature of diplomacy itself. High-stakes negotiations, especially between adversaries who have not engaged at this level in decades, do not culminate in instant breakthroughs. — FILE
The issue is no longer simply whether Baloch grievances exist, but whether western outlets are flattening a violent and legally complicated landscape into a morality play with one heroine and one villain. — FILE/THE THURSDAY TIMES
Pakistan is intensifying quiet diplomacy with Washington, Tehran and Gulf capitals in an effort to prevent the US-Israel-Iran conflict from spiralling further and to position Islamabad as a possible venue for peace talks. — COLLAGE/THE THURSDAY TIMES

The BBC’s one-sided Kandahar narrative

A broadcaster like the BBC must do more than relay claims; it must test them. When it gives one side’s language prominence while sidelining the other’s evidence and security case, it stops just reporting and starts shaping a narrative.

Audiences today are not passive. They compare footage, statements, satellite imagery, and open-source analysis in real time. — FILE/THE THURSDAY TIMES
akistan has publicly condemned attacks on Iran and on Gulf states, while insisting that the region cannot be stabilised through force. Islamabad says the only serious path forward is restraint, de-escalation and talks. — COLLAGE/THE THURSDAY TIMES
Pakistan has shut down talk of backchannel peace talks, saying there will be no dialogue unless Kabul first takes concrete and verifiable action against militants operating from Afghan soil. — FILE/THE THURSDAY TIMES

Bias masquerading as expertise

The Diplomat’s piece rests on Ajmal Sohail’s unverified claims, presenting a politically situated Afghan figure as a neutral expert while offering no credible independent evidence for its most serious allegations. It also fails the basic logic test: Pakistan’s all-weather partnership with China makes the claim that Islamabad is targeting Chinese interests extremely difficult to sustain.

The Diplomat relies on Ajmal Sohail’s unverified claims, presents a politically situated Afghan figure as a neutral expert, and ignores the basic reality that Pakistan’s all-weather partnership with China makes such allegations hard to sustain. — FILE

US weapons are turning up in Pakistan’s war zone

A claim by US Congressman Ryan Zinke that Taliban fighters in Pakistan are using American Humvees and M16s has revived Pakistan’s long-running warning about post-2021 weapons spillover, as Pakistani reporting cites CNN-linked serial checks and alleged recoveries of US-origin kit in KP and Balochistan.

Weapons left behind after the US withdrawal from Afghanistan are increasingly appearing in militant attacks in Pakistan, raising concerns about regional instability and the long-term security consequences of unregulated military stockpiles. — MONTAGE/THE THURSDAY TIMES
A viral X post is being miscast as an official Israeli source to push a false claim that Pakistan and Gulf states are aligning with Israel, even though Islamabad’s posture is deterrence and de-escalation aimed at preventing regional spillover. — FILE / THE THURSDAY TIMES
Published by Thursday Media International thursday.media